Photo by Mark Von Holden, WireImageGwyneth Paltrow and Joaquin Phoenix at the New York Cinema Society screening of Two Lovers - 02/11/2009

Photo by Mark Von Holden, WireImageVinessa Shaw at the New York Cinema Society screening of Two Lovers - 02/11/2009

Photo by Michael Loccisano, Getty ImagesHilary Duff at the New York Cinema Society screening of Two Lovers - 02/11/2009

Photo by Mark Von Holden, WireImageJohn Leguizamo and Andrew Saffir at the New York Cinema Society screening of Two Lovers - 02/11/2009

Photo by Mark Von Holden, WireImageHelena Christensen at the New York Cinema Society screening of Two Lovers - 02/11/2009

Photo by Michael Loccisano, Getty ImagesJoaquin Phoenix at the New York Cinema Society screening of Two Lovers - 02/11/2009

Photo by Jim Spellman, WireImageGwyneth Paltrow at the New York Cinema Society screening of Two Lovers - 02/11/2009

Photo by Michael Loccisano, Getty ImagesEva Amurri at the New York Cinema Society screening of Two Lovers - 02/11/2009

Photo by Mark Von Holden, WireImageTaylor Momsen at the New York Cinema Society screening of Two Lovers - 02/11/2009

Photo by Mark Von Holden, WireImageGwyneth Paltrow, Joaquin Phoenix and Vinessa Shaw at the New York Cinema Society screening of Two Lovers - 02/11/2009

Photo by Michael Loccisano, Getty ImagesMichael Stipe at the New York Cinema Society screening of Two Lovers - 02/11/2009

Photo by Mark Von Holden, WireImageJoaquin Phoenix at the New York Cinema Society screening of Two Lovers - 02/11/2009

Photo by Mark Von Holden, WireImageGwyneth Paltrow at the New York Cinema Society screening of Two Lovers - 02/11/2009

Photo by Mark Von Holden, WireImageVinessa Shaw and Phylicia Rashad at the New York Cinema Society screening of Two Lovers - 02/11/2009

Photo by Mark Von Holden, WireImageHelena Christensen at the New York Cinema Society screening of Two Lovers - 02/11/2009

Photo by Michael Loccisano, Getty ImagesHilary Duff at the New York Cinema Society screening of Two Lovers - 02/11/2009

Photo by Mark Von Holden, WireImageDirector James Gray and Gwyneth Paltrow at the New York Cinema Society screening of Two Lovers - 02/11/2009

Photo by Michael Loccisano, Getty ImagesVinessa Shaw at the New York Cinema Society screening of Two Lovers - 02/11/2009

Photo by Ray Tamarra, Getty ImagesTaylor Momsen at the New York Cinema Society screening of Two Lovers - 02/11/2009

Photo by Mark Von Holden, WireImagePhylicia Rashad at the New York Cinema Society screening of Two Lovers - 02/11/2009

Photo by Mark Von Holden, WireImageEva Amurri and Chris Benz at the New York Cinema Society screening of Two Lovers - 02/11/2009

Photo by Mark Von Holden, WireImageHelena Christensen and Michael Stipe at the New York Cinema Society screening of Two Lovers - 02/11/2009

Photo by Mark Von Holden, WireImageVinessa Shaw and Taylor Momsen at the New York Cinema Society screening of Two Lovers - 02/11/2009

Photo by Mark Von Holden, WireImageOlivia Palermo at the New York Cinema Society screening of Two Lovers - 02/11/2009

Photo by Mark Von Holden, WireImageRachel Zoe, Natalia Vondianova and Byrdie Bell at the New York Cinema Society screening of Two Lovers - 02/11/2009

Photo by Mark Von Holden, WireImageCasey Affleck at the New York Cinema Society screening of Two Lovers - 02/11/2009