About an hour into Ladder 49, I was ready to become a
fireman. Because according to the first half of the movie, being a
fireman means lots of drinking, practical jokes, and chicks, with a
bit of firefighting to break up the monotony. But by the second half,
I realized what the film was doing: setting up a character's heroic
climb to the top, only to knock him down. The character is Jack
Morrison (Joaquin Phoenix), a rookie when we meet him, all too
experienced when we say goodbye. We meet Jack fresh out of whatever
school that firefighters attend. Within five screen minutes, he's
being punk'd by captain Mike Kennedy (John Travolta) while a fireman
named Lenny (Robert Patrick), pretending to be a priest, hears his
confession. It's all in the spirit of "hazing the new guy," but it
becomes clear that the film deals in a currency of emotional
shortcuts. What helps is Phoenix. While I could never quite figure out
his appeal as an actor, here his pudgy face and trademark facial scar
become our entry into the movie. He stays grounded and simple in a
film whose layer of gloss is so thick that even the gathering clouds
of inevitable tragedy can't sand it down.
The film begins with
a ten-minute prologue involving Morrison and the rest of the company
fighting an enormous warehouse fire in Baltimore. After saving a
civilian, the floor underneath Jack collapses and he tumbles down
multiple stories. Hurt and immobile, he waits to be rescued while
flashing back to the major moments in his life. Although the flashback
structure is not unappealing, it ultimately works against the film. No
one expects an injured and possibly dying man to recall the boring
moments of his life. So Jack (and as a result, the film) is stuck with
an overly prettified highlight reel that moves too fast and slick. In
too short order, Jack settles into his firefighting gig and marries
Linda (Jacinda Barrett), who then cranks out two kids. Every scene
seems maximized for ultimate camaraderie, with only brief glimpses of
what it must really be like to live in a firehouse. Eventually, the
tone darkens as the team begins taking casualties and Linda expresses
familiar fears about becoming a fireman's widow. The narrative
doesn't lack for big events, but the harder the film tries, the more
we realize what's missing. None of these characters are explored in
any depth. All we know about Mike Kennedy is that he's divorced and he
owns at least two pairs of funny underwear. Most of the others exist
merely to be heroic. Also, we never get a sense of what's mentally
required to be a fireman, or why people become fireman, other than it
helps them land hot girls. Those who choose to become police officers
or fireman or soldiers or reality show contestants approach life
differently than the rest of us. Ladder 49 fails to get
inside the heads of its characters and, with the exception of Jack,
doesn't even try.
Director Jay Russell makes sure that plenty
of flames blow out plenty of windows, but without fully developed
characters it's all just a technical exercise. Travolta, whose close-
cropped haircut makes his head look perfectly round, just doesn't seem
right. He's best as a cool customer (Get Shorty, Saturday
Night Fever, Pulp Fiction). As the heart-of-gold leader
of sweaty, death-defying men, the cracks show in his acting. The more
grounded he tries to make himself, the less I believe him. With the
exception of Barrett, who makes the most of a by-the-numbers part,
none of the others distinguish themselves, nor have they been given
the tools to do so. The bland score by William Ross doesn't help, its
cliched Irish lilt giving way to a horrible Robbie Robertson-penned
song at a crucial moment.
There's a lot be said for those who
rush into fires while everyone else rushes out. But Ladder 49
gave me nothing I haven't heard before, or couldn't have figured out
myself. It was undoubtedly made with the best of intentions, but the
storytelling is so broad, the film is ultimately rendered unnecessary.
The Video: How Does The Disc Look?
The film's theatrical aspect ratio of 1.85 is presented in
anamorphic video. The results are outstanding. Although much of the
film takes place at night or inside darkened buildings, blacks are
mostly very dark and very dense. Shadow detail stays generally
excellent, with pixilation and compression artifacts held at bay. An
occasional shot will look murky, but considering the inherent
difficulty in transferring such a dark film, we'll forgive these tiny
infractions. The color palette is very wide, even though all the
colors of the rainbow aren't represented all the time. Only over the
course of the film, with daytime exteriors and night interiors (and
vice versa) do we realize how many colors are represented. And it's
all very bright and confident. Reds don't tear, whites don't seem
blown out, and the green of the local pub doesn't smear at all. Detail
is good, although there are some items I should've been able to read
(like wall charts) that I could not. Also, some of the medium shots
looked soft. The daytime exteriors are very smooth and filmlike. Edge
halos do rear their thin, ugly head occasionally, but I found it
nothing to worry about. There were zero print defects. Flesh tones are
natural and contrast is above average. It's a terrific transfer with
one or two tiny problems that shouldn't bother you.
The Audio: How Does The Disc Sound?
The
Dolby Digital 5.1 track is augmented by something Buena Vista is
calling an Enhanced Home Theater Mix. Disney has also utilized this
vague, but promising-sounding concept on the Mary Poppins DVD
and the Aladdin DVD. It does live up to the hype, however.
Ladder 49 sounds great. Most benefiting from the added aural
effort are the fire scenes. The flames, with their crackling sounds
and rumblings are completely immersive. They fill the room, utilizing
all channels. The bigger sounds, like explosions and the crumbling of
buildings also sound great, with aural detail and confident bass
raising it above the norm. The dialogue is clean and understandable.
The mix is well balanced among effects, dialogue, and music. Good
effort from Buena Vista.
There is also a French Dolby Digital
5.1 track and English, French, and Spanish subtitles.
Supplements: What Goodies Are There?
Being
a director is a lot like being a fireman: you spend most of your time
putting out fires. And the supplements provided give you some idea of
how hard it was to put this film together and how hard it is to be a
fireman.
The Making of Ladder 49 is
a 21 minute featurette that can be played all at once or in three
separate chunks, On Location, Fire Academy: Training the
Actors, and Anatomy of a Scene: The Warehouse Fire.
According to the piece, Baltimore was picked because it was specific
and photogenic and underused in the movies. Director Jay Russell also
admits that Baltimore was perfect since the city would let the
production burn whatever they wanted. Russell also says that Phoenix
was afraid of heights when they first met, but by the end, he was
doing many of his own stunts. There is even footage of Travolta
singeing his hands during a shot and the medics attending to him. All
of the actors spent two weeks training at the Baltimore Fire Academy.
There is good footage of the training program, giving you a sense of
how complicated it is to be a firefighter. The major fire of the film
was shot at an abandoned grain silo and the final third of the
featurette explains into how dangerous it was to shoot there, and how
the stunt people checked and double-checked everything to insure
safety. All the filmmakers are interviewed, including producer Casey
Silver and writer Lewis Colick. The full screen behind-the-scenes
footage looks quite good and even the full screen film clips look
terrific.
Everyday Heroes is a 14-
minute tribute to what makes firefighters tick. There are nice
interviews with many real Baltimore firefighters, including Lt. Donald
Schafer from Engine Company 5. We meet him at home, getting ready to
receive an award for bravery. He has a wife and two daughters, and God
knows if they ever stop worrying about the safety of their father.
Everyday Heroes is a nice piece that salutes real heroes. It
also reminds you that this 14-minute extra is more emotional then the
entirety of Ladder 49. The full screen footage looks great.
Next are Deleted Scenes. There are five in
all, totaling about 14 minutes. Lunch Room Conversation is
just three minutes of unnecessary small talk. Jack and Linda's
First Date is slow, but at least it's character oriented,
something the picture sorely needs. Captain Tony Arrives is
about the arrival of a new captain, a buttoned-down tool whom our
hardy heroes don't immediately like. Ray's Subplot answers
the question: What was Balthazar Getty doing in this movie? In this
three-minute scene, Getty's character admits he's going into rehab for
a drinking problem. This would have worked better if his drinking
problem were tied to the pressure of being a fireman. But instead, his
problem comes out of nowhere. The most interesting deleted scene is
9-11. In it, Phoenix comes home to a news report that the
World Trade Center was attacked. It's an odd moment that was better
left on the cutting room floor. All the clips seem outputted from an
Avid, so they look good, but not as good as the finished film.
There is an audio commentary by director Jay
Russell and editor Bud Smith. Despite some very long patches of
silence, their comments are interesting and conversational. Russell
discusses how the fireballs were created and how much preparation went
into making the movie as authentic looking as possible. It's a nice
listen, although it must be said that their voices are too harsh,
which is annoying.
Finally, there is a music
video for Robbie Robertson's "Shine Your Light," a song that
ruins a somber moment in the film.
Exclusive DVD-ROM
Features: What happens when you pop the disc into your PC?
There are no DVD-ROM features on this DVD.
Final Thoughts
If Sam Raimi's Spider-
Man has taught us anything, it's that all the special effects in
the world won't save a film whose heroes fail to express real
emotions, doubts and fears. Ladder 49 features terrific fire
sequences that took weeks to plan, but it's all for naught without
characters I care about. As for the DVD, the picture and sound are
wonderful and the extras are nice enough. The problem is the film. I
already know firefighters are heroes. Next time, tell me something I
don't know.