Movies   DVD   My Movies 
Search Yahoo! Movies:  
   Research before you buy! DVD Home    Top Sellers    DVD Reviews   
Yahoo! Movies > On DVD/Video > DVD Reviews > Story
 DVD Reviews
DVDFile.com
Winged Migration
January 13, 2004 - Dan Ramer, DVDFile.com
Seven years ago, the theatrical release of Fly Away Home gave us a glimpse of the airborne migration of Canadian Geese as Amy Alden and her dad, Tom, imprinted their adopted birds with memories of the route to their winter home to the South. In my review, I mentioned that, "Director Carroll Ballard and cinematographer Caleb Deschanel create wonderful images of an unlikely formation of machine and waterfowl soaring over forest and mountain. The film is worth a buy just for the aerial scenes." Two years after Fly Away Home was released and perhaps inspired by those images, a team of three directors and fifteen cinematographers began a four-year journey on seven continents to photograph the similar images of Winged Migration.

 More about this DVD
 •  DVD Info
 •  Movie Main Page
 •  Message Board
Jacques Perrin narrates the film and I was pleased to find that his contribution is minimal. Rather than lecturing the viewer on scientific minutia concerning animal behavior and migration in particular, the filmmakers allow the images to speak to the audience. The soundtrack is dominated by a score composed by Bruno Coulais, the sounds of nature, and of the wind. We're transported into a lyrical world inhabited by those feathered creatures with the wonderful ability to fly, a world in which the food chain comes very much into play.

Four years of effort and hundreds of hours of footage have been distilled into an annual cycle of migration depicted over the course of eighty-nine minutes. We follow several species - geese, ducks, cranes, pelicans - as they make the yearly commute to feed, court, mate, reproduce, and ensure the survival of their respective species. We're also treated to sequences involving other birds that share the territories inhabited by the animals we follow through the sky. (I was aware that there are both migratory and non-migratory birds, but I did not know that eagles migrate.)

The journeys of thousands of miles are not easy. Weather and exhaustion claim victims. And the migrating birds find themselves at risk from predators, including other birds and the animal at the very top of the food chain, man. Hunters prey on the waterfowl, luring them with realistic decoys and blowing them from the sky with shoguns. Migrating birds fear of man equip them with an instinctive avoidance that serves them reasonably well, but there is a more modern threat, one that evolution hasn't had time to address, pollution. But I don't want to create the impression that the film concentrates on the harshness of life; it does not. DVDFile.com Photo

The filmmakers have captured remarkable scenes of birds in flight, expending great energy to travel surprising distances. We join the birds in their winter and summer homes, enjoying glimpses of their full life cycles. The film is a towering achievement, leaving the viewer to wonder how the filmmakers did it. All is revealed in the supplements. But before you satisfy your curiosity, simply sit back and enjoy the ethereal experience of being among those creatures that truly experience life in three dimensions. Don't expect to be lectured on the minutia of migratory bird science; this is simply a visual feast, an opportunity to experience life from another creature's point of view.

Video: How Does The Disc Look?

The film's theatrical aspect ratio of 1.85:1 is presented in anamorphic video. This is a very respectable presentation from Columbia TriStar, but in the end, I was disappointed. The color accuracy is terrific. The bright colors of tropical Macaws are vividly painted to the screen with no chroma noise or smearing. Shadow detail during the night scenes is excellent. I noticed no macroblocking or mosquito noise. Even edge halos are more suppressed here than in most conventional Columbia TriStar releases. My biggest problem with this DVD is its image resolution. Small object detail is merely average, and fine textures like the intricate structure of feathers is not as well defined as I would have liked. Shots angled downward reveal forests as indistinct tufts of green. The film's beautiful images are simply not conveyed with the level of detail they deserve. I was left with the impression that the images were low-passed to reduce the film's bit budget and ensure there would be adequate room on this single disc for the generous supplements.

Audio: How Does The Disc Sound? DVDFile.com Photo

The Dolby Digital 5.1 track is a delight. This is not an official EX mix, but I found that enabling EX decoding was a more immersive experience. As we soar through the sky, the dominant sounds are the wind and the delicate flapping of wings. The viewer is plunged into this aerial sea of sound, creating the delightful illusion of being among the birds. Exceptionally deep bass will require a superior subwoofer; thunder and an avalanche are very persuasive. The eclectic score by Bruno Coulais is an odd blend of orchestral motifs, childrens' voices, and a small male chorus chanting in heavy rhythmic breathing. These sequences are supplemented with the occasional solo male voice, singing a more contemporary ballad. The music is presented across a broad soundstage, sometimes locating musical sources in the surround speakers. The fidelity is surprisingly good. The modest dialog is always distortion-free, devoid of digital compression raspiness.

Subtitles are provided in Hindi, Portuguese, Spanish, and English, for which Closed Captions are also available.

Supplements: What Goodies Are There? DVDFile.com Photo

When we learn in the supplements that this film is essentially a staged nature documentary, we're no less amazed. The filmmakers exploited a predisposition of these migratory birds made so clear in Fly Away Home: the being a hatchling first encounters as it emerges from its shell is imprinted as its parent. Several species of large migratory birds are raised from egg to adolescent. The birds are conditioned to accept the noisy machines that the filmmakers will use to create their movie, among them trucks, powerboats, and ultralights. Each parent spends all his or her time with their birds, feeding them, petting them, holding them, even sleeping with the birds at their sides. The bonding worked exceedingly well. The birds eagerly follow each camera platform when their "parent" is onboard. When each species becomes old enough to be taken on its migratory route, the filmmakers mount up and began their adventures.

Columbia TriStar Home Entertainment has included many supplements that describe this process end to end. First is a commentary by director Jacques Perrin. This is the only extra spoken in English (the rest are in French with forced English subtitles) and a bit of concentration may be required to understand Perrin's charming accent. He goes into considerable detail about the making of the film, but he also waxes philosophic about the nature of life as a bird and the appreciation he and his fellow filmmakers developed for their adopted children. Not to worry... The full screen Making of Featurette (52:13) provides greater insights and a comprehensive behind the scenes view of the film. It's here that we come to fully appreciate the filmmakers' ingenuity and persistence. The magic behind many of the shots that viewers will find both beautiful and incomprehensible is revealed.

The eclectic score by Bruno Coulais is the focus of the full screen Creating the Music Featurette (17:23). The composer shares his inspirations and the means by which he satisfied the director's wishes. The source of some of the oddest sequences, like the panting chants, was difficult to identify during the film; in this featurette, we see them performed. Somewhat interesting, but a bit dry.

The rest of the supplements are presented in anamorphic video. There are two sequences of Filmmaker Interviews: About the Film (9:44) and Further Insights (14:05). This supplement extends our view beyond the director's to some of the other participants. It is a combination of a philosophic appreciation of the natural world, a description of the relationships among the filmmakers and the birds, and the challenges and dangers of capturing these images on film. The Photo Gallery with Filmmaker Commentary (13:17) is a lovely collection of images that become a visual background to another deeply detailed discussion. The feature is organized based on species. We learn more about them and more about how they were filmed. There are two Trailers on this DVD: Winged Migration (1:59) and a promo for Varekai - Cirque Du Soleil (0:31).

The 89-minute documentary is organized into twenty-four chapters.

DVD-ROM Exclusives: What do you get when you pop the disc in your PC?

A Flash file opens upon loading the DVD into your computer. A number of menu item are then available. You may visit the Winged Migration Web Site, Columbia TriStar home page, or Columbia TriStar's DVD site. If your computer behaves like my Windows XP machine, don't expect your browser to pop up when you press any of those choices. A copy of the browser does open and loads the page, but stays in the background, quite invisible. In my impatience, repeated clicking opened five instances of Internet Explorer, all displaying the same web page. Be prepared to manually sequence to the browser window to see the selected site.

Parting Thoughts

This is a lovely DVD. The film is captivating, more involving than many feature films with intricate plots. The beautiful images are virtually hypnotic. While I was disappointed with the quality of the video, the sound is great and the very generous quality supplements have an aggregate running time that exceeds the feature film by over twenty minutes. Highly recommended.


More DVD Reviews...

 
 


Yahoo! Movies: In Theaters - Times & Tickets - Trailers - DVD - News & Gossip - Box Office - Browse Movies - more...
Yahoo! Entertainment: Movies - Music - TV - Games - Astrology - more...