I must begin with an admission of prejudice; I've never been an
Adam Sandler fan. I found his humor sophomoric and unfocussed on
Saturday Night Live and his big screen persona was not an
improvement. Then came Punch Drunk Love. Sandler was delightful
in a role that was tailor-made for him by writer/director Paul Thomas
Anderson. I had hoped that Punch Drunk Love's public and
critical reception would have motivated Sandler's appreciation for
quality and more sophisticated roles. I was to be disappointed. By the
time I had finished spinning this screener, I was a candidate for
Anger Management.
The concept is intriguing. Dave Buznik
(Adam Sandler) is bright and creative but finds himself in a dead-end
job in which his boss takes credit for his work. His dedicated
girlfriend, Linda (Marisa Tomei), tolerates his neuroses, very likely
triggered by a painful preadolescence, the continual brunt of bullies
and Arnie Shankman in particular. Through circumstances too bizarre to
believe, Buznick finds himself before Judge Brenda Daniels (Lynne
Thigpen), accused of assaulting a flight attendant. His clueless
lawyer, Sam (Kevin Nealon), is of little help. Buznick is found guilty
and instructed to attend anger management training with the renowned
Dr. Buddy Rydell (Jack Nicholson). Buznick's arc is very
Kafkaesque; his innocuous behavior provokes inexplicable reactions.
His fellow anger group members are indeed suffering from
uncontrollable outbursts of rage. Among them are Lou (Luis Guzman), a
playfully violent homosexual, and Chuck (John Turturro), a paranoid
rage-aholic who believes that serving for several hours in Grenada
entitles him to the same consideration earned by veterans who served
in Vietnam for years. When these two act out during a session, Rydell
is helpful and supportive, but when Buznick says anything, he's
treated like a dangerous psycho.
And that sets the tone of the
film. The reactions to Buznick's mild behavior are so unlikely and out
of proportion that the viewer is left wondering what the hell is going
on. For over an hour and a half, Rydell tortures Buznick
psychologically, humiliating him, putting him in situations that would
cause any normal person to flee to the closest asylum. We're forced to
accept the notion that Buznick cooperates with the good doctor because
if he doesn't, he'd be thrown in jail for a year. But Rydell's methods
are so unorthodox that I wasn't sure whether this was a fantasy
aspiring to humor or simply a misguided comedy. During the climax an
explanation revealed, leaving the viewer to wonder who's paying the
bills? 
Nicholson, consistently inventive and fascinating to
watch, could have saved the show, but perhaps sensing a lack of
creative direction, seems to have overcompensated by going a bit over
the top. And Sandler returns to a character consistent with his
familiar screen persona. Even before I watched the supplements, I came
to suspect that making the film was fun for the filmmakers and the
players, but I'm disappointed that the sense of fun wasn't transferred
to the audience. And there's some sloppiness here as well. During the
incident at the elevator-based parking garage, the owner rather than
an attendant drives the car, and the elevator operator abandons the
driver, conveniently leaving a vast chasm for the gag. These two
circumstances short-circuited my willing suspension of disbelief,
something to be avoided in a reality-based comedy. Somewhat later in
the film, if you look carefully at the procession of cars behind
Rydell's Range Rover just after they escape from the monastery, you
can clearly see the filmmakers' police car escort at the back of the
line, strobe lights flashing. The director ignored it in the editing
room and during the commentary.
And yet, the film did attract a
surprising number of actors and celebrities for cameos. Woody
Harrelson is the outrageous Galaxia (and Garry the Guard), an
uncredited Heather Graham plays Kendra, a lovely woman with a body
image problem, an uncredited John C. Reilly is the adult Arnie
Shankman in retreat at a Buddhist monastery, and also uncredited is
Harry Dean Stanton as a blind man accidentally clocked by Buznick. You
will also find John McEnroe, Rudolph Giuliani, Judith Nathan, Roger
Clemens, Cody Arens, Bobby Knight, Tony Carbonetti, Bob Sheppard,
Robert Merrill, Sid Ganis, and Derek Jeter. I have to admit that I did
enjoy a few laughs, but it doesn't bode well when the cameos are more
entertaining than the film.
Video: How Does The Disc
Look?
The film's theatrical aspect ratio of 2.40:1 is
presented in anamorphic video. The disc's video is typical of recent
releases from Columbia-Tristar Home Entertainment. Color rendition
based on flesh tones is extremely natural. Saturated colors are
painted to the screen with no chroma noise or smearing. Shadow detail
is excellent, as is small object detail. Finely grained textures are
above average, but not exceptional. Compression artifacts are not
visible. And the video is slightly contaminated with edge halos that
are sometimes visible but never intrude. Strangely enough, as I
consider this conventional DVD's video quality I would give the edge
over the recent Superbit release of Leon The Professional.

Audio: How Does The Disc Sound?
The disc's Dolby
Digital 5.1 track is fine. Discrete surround sounds are heard from
time to time, but the audio is predominantly in the front channels. EX
decoding will neither help nor hinder this particular audio track.
Sound effects are not an issue here; they are designed to serve the
visuals as a mix of practical, Foley, and library sounds. I noticed no
extended bass. Teddy Castellucci's sweet orchestral score sounds very
good, with a pleasant sense of spaciousness and with pleasing
fidelity. The dialog remains clear throughout without a hint of
compression raspiness.
The alternate language is in French,
also presented in Dolby Digital 5.1. Subtitles are provided in French
and English, for which Closed Captions are also available.

Supplements: What Goodies Are There?
Columbia-Tristar
Home Entertainment has included a nice array of extras on this special
edition DVD. The first supplement is a screen-specific audio
commentary by director Peter Segal and Adam Sandler. For the most
part, Segal and Sandler just watch the film and joke around. (Segal
enjoys Sandler more than I do; he certainly giggled more than I did.)
But ever once in a while, Segal would offer a relevant comment
concerning the film. He comments on locations, shooting challenges,
and special effects. I was surprised at the number of CGI shots in
this film - with the exception of a Lexus, they are very well
integrated, particularly the thousands of Spidermen dressed in civies
at Yankee Stadium.
Next is the Do You Have Anger
Problems? game, an inconsistent, tongue-in-cheek multiple-choice
quiz that questions your judgment based on little excerpts from the
film. There are four deleted scenes (10:16, aggregate) on this
DVD. Most elevate Buznick's frustration level and perhaps the
audience's; that may be why it was decided to delete them from the
theatrical cut. The fourth is cute, John McEnroe acting out; I liked
the development of a tennis metaphor in the bickering. The scene also
explains how McEnroe ended up on that couch during one the anger
management group sessions. 
There are two featurettes on
this disc: Skull Session (17:54); and, My Buddy Jack
(4:06). The first is a making-of short that provides glimpses of
behind the scenes. We hear from various players and filmmakers who
describe the origins of the film and attest to the fun they had on the
shoot. Don't be surprised if you find many of the outtakes found on
the blooper reel here. Some time is spent discussing costume design
and the look of the film. It's a bit fluffy, but informative. The
second is a tribute to Jack Nicholson. Be prepared for a lot of
fawning.
The Bloopers Reel (5:36) is a bit of a hoot. My
favorite section is a scantily clad Heather Graham trying
unsuccessfully to keep it together while stuffing chocolate cupcakes
in her mouth. There are ten trailers on this DVD: Anger
Management (2:30); Adam Sandler's Eight Crazy Nights
(1:21); As Good As It Gets (2:30); Daddy Day Care
(2:19); S.W.A.T. (1:50); Hollywood Homicide (2:32);
Mona Lisa Smiles (2:32); Mr. Deeds (2:28); Radio
(2:32); and, Peter Pan (2:13). The 106-minute feature is
organized into twenty-eight chapters.
DVD-ROM Exclusives:
What do you get when you pop the disc in your PC?
No ROM
extras have been included.
Parting Thoughts
I
have very mixed feelings about this disc. There is a chuckle or two to
be had and the supplements are somewhat interesting, but this is an
unlikely candidate for a second viewing (with the possible exception
of sitting through the commentary). My recommendation for the curious
would be a rental.