As I began to prepare this review, I went into the DVDFILE
archives to seek a review from a previous release. It's the reviewer's
option to take advantage of the site's previously published plot
summaries and film critiques if they're available. When there's
disagreement between the original reviewer and the current reviewer, a
counterpoint may be added (I inserted one at the end of our esteemed
editor's critique when I reviewed the Collector's Edition of Black
Hawk Down). It was with some bewilderment that I discovered that
we seem to have missed all previous releases for this fine film, one
that ranks second among the American Film Institute's Top 100 American
Films, sixth among the Internet Movie Database's Top 250, and is
consistently ranked among the top ten best movies of all time by every
film reviewer I've read. So it's with great pleasure that I offer a
few thoughts about Casablanca.
The very familiar story
takes place in unoccupied France during the Second World War. The
Nazis are in Paris. A puppet government has been set up in Vichy. In
French Morocco, refugees fleeing the brutal Nazi conquerors stream
into Casablanca hoping to bribe or buy their ways to sanctuary in
America. The most popular nightspot in town is Cafe Americain, owned
and run by an expatriate American, Rick Blaine (Humphrey Bogart). He
projects an image of selfish self-interest, forsaking allegiances to
maintain the strict neutrality of a businessman who wants to stay in
business. No less self-serving is Captain Louis Renault (Claude
Rains), prefect of police and friend, but a friend who seems
uncomfortably cooperative with the Nazi overlords. Having fled
Paris as the Germans approached, deserted by the love of his life,
Ilsa Lund Laszlo (Ingrid Bergman), Blaine was not prepared when she
walks into his gin joint. And he certainly didn't want to see her on
the arm of another man, Victor Laszlo (Paul Henreid), an underground
leader of the French Resistance. They, too, are fleeing the Nazis.
Laszlo wishes to escape to safety so that he may continue his work
unimpeded. The Nazis are aware of his presence in Casablanca and wish
to detain him there, neutralizing his influence. The means to escape
takes the form of letters of transit, stolen from the bodies of two
murdered German officers by Guillermo Ugarte (Peter Lorre). The
letters might be considered a Hitchcockian Macguffin, but they're more
than that. A Macguffin is a distraction, a mechanism to provoke the
story the filmmaker wants to tell; here they play a vital role. Like
the stolen plans for the Death Star, they will provide the means for
the film's resolution.
I will not attempt to place Casablanca
in any particular genre. It is foremost a love story of two people
with bitter regrets who come to terms with their feelings. It is an
action piece that, for its time, is typically anti-Nazi. And it's
laced with humor, from Blaine's sardonic comments to Renault's
sarcastic wit. Made during a decade when motion picture studios were
cranking out fifty films each year, this was considered just another
flick by the filmmakers, the players, and Warner Bros. But like that
statistically valid cliche - if you put an infinite number of monkeys
in front of an infinite number of typewriters all the world's past and
future works of literature will ultimately be typed out - the odds
favored the production of a few exceptional films within that vast
output. This does not diminish in any way the talents and instincts of
the featured actors and the behind-the-scenes artists; it simply
indicates that, once in a while, magic happens. 
Casablanca is
wonderfully economical. Each scene drives the story forward, revealing
the characters, exposing psychological baggage, creating conflicts on
several levels that must be resolved by film's end. The screenplay is
a delightful balance of melodrama, drama, action, and humor; none seem
out of place. The casting is a synergistic delight. Humphrey Bogart's
Rick Blaine has wrapped himself in a hard, cynical shell to hide his
soft center of sentimentality and vulnerability. Ingrid Bergman's Ilsa
Lund Laszlo is believably conflicted, an emotional wreck being pulled
apart by her love for two men, one based on passion and the other on a
deep respect and admiration. How many can resist tearing up as her
eyes glisten with moisture?
Claude Rains'
Captain Louis Renault is playfully corrupt, flexible in his
allegiances until his innate goodness overcomes his avarice and
lechery. Sydney Greenstreet is still the man who likes to do business
with a man who likes to do business; his Signor Ferrari is merely a
cameo, but his presence is most welcome. Another cameo is by Peter
Lorre, seen all too briefly as the slimy Guillermo Ugarte. That some
of the other characters fall somewhat flat, like Paul Henreid's Victor
Laszlo, an underground leader with no charisma, or are borderline
caricatures, like Conrad Veidt's Major Heinrich Strasser, the arrogant
Nazi officer everyone loves to hate, must be ignored (as do the
obviously artificial special effects). Casablanca is simply too good a
film, and minor flaws are gladly forgiven.
Video: How Does
The Disc Look?
The black and white film's theatrical aspect
ratio of 1.37:1 is presented in full screen. This is another fine
transfer from Warner. The presentation is wonderfully detailed, from
fine textures to the small object details in sharp focus in the
background. So crisp and clean is this DVD that the matte painting in
the opening sequence and the softening of the images by the
cinematographer during Bergman's close-ups are quite clear. There are
deep rich blacks, yet shadow detail within the film's shadow-strewn
lighting and during the night scenes is first-rate. Edge halos are
essentially absent. Bravo. The film elements look pristine, thanks to
a loving restoration by Lowry Digital Images, the same folks who did
such a splendid job on North by Northwest. Subtle scratches and
dirt may be found only in some stock war footage, very likely left
intact as an artistic decision. We're left with very film-like
images.
Audio: How Does The Disc Sound? 
The Dolby
Digital 1.0 sound for a film made over sixty years ago is surprisingly
good. As you would expect from a film of that era, the bandwidth and
dynamic range are limited, yet the distortion level is substantially
lower than I had expected. The dialog is very clear and isn't
contaminated by the raspiness sometimes heard in compressed digital
audio tracks. It's the sound effects and music that suffer most from
the obsolete audio. Max Steiner's fine orchestral score, much of it
variations on a theme from Herman Hupfeld's song, "As Time Goes
By," is nasal and claustrophobic. Gunshots most dramatically
demonstrate the weaknesses of the old technology; they are messy,
smeared, and highly compressed. But the dialog is key, and it's better
here than in many DVDs of more recent films.
The alternative
language is French. The audio is supported by subtitles in French,
Spanish, and English, for which Closed Captions are also provided.
Supplements: What Goodies Are There? 
The extensive
supplements are divided between two discs. On disc one, there is an
understandably affectionate introduction by Lauren Bacall
(2:05). It's optional and will automatically branch to the film upon
its completion. There are two feature-length commentaries on
this disc. One is by film critic Roger Ebert; the other is by
film historian Rudy Behlmer.
Listening to Ebert is
like attending a lecture in film school. He translates the language of
film, conveying the meaning of lighting, framing, and composition. We
learn how the filmmakers created the illusion of reversing the
disparity in height between Bogart and Bergman; she was apparently two
inches taller. He explains how lighting was used to shape Bergman's
face, and how she preferred her left profile. Ebert differentiates
between Casablanca myths and historical truths, dispelling the
notion that the ending wasn't written until the day that scene was
shot. He's engaging and entertaining.
As he provided for the
DVDs of Notorious, The Invisible Man, and
Frankenstein, film historian Rudy Behlmer offers a richly
detailed lecture. He reveals the history behind the making of the
film, casting details, anecdotes from the set, biographical
information about the principles, and some shooting techniques. His
historical perspective is more entertaining and informative than many
commentary tracks found on other DVDs. It's very well done.
A Great Cast is Worth Repeating is a series of text screens
that resembles “two degrees of freedom.” In anecdotal style, the
author mentions the films in which Casablanca's notable players
appeared together. This takes the place of more traditional
biographies and filmographies, which you might have expected in the
Cast & Crew section. That single page of text simply lists
the principles. Other Legendary Titles Available From Warner Home
Video previews, with theatrical trailers, three popular
movies about to be released on DVD: The Treasure of the Sierra
Madre, Yankee Doodle Dandy, and the film I'm most looking
forward to this September, the 1938 production of The Adventures of
Robin Hood starring Errol Flynn. Warner Home Video has also
included both Casablanca's original theatrical trailer
and the re-release trailer from 1992.
The rest of the
supplements are found on the second disc. In The Children
Remember (6:46), a newly produced short, Stephen Bogart and Pia
Lindstrom reminisce about their recollections of their parents'
stories about the making of the film. This is the puff piece of the
disc set. Bogart and Lindstrom, who respectively have noticeable
resemblances to their father and mother, talk about what the film
means to them and what the film meant to their parents.
Quite
remarkably, two deleted scenes survive to be included.
Unfortunately, the audio no longer exists, so forced subtitles have
been added to provide dialog. One scene resolves the question about
the deal Laszlo made with Blaine to get him and Ilsa out of
Casablanca. Equally surprising are the outtakes that have
survived, even if they too are silent. They seem like alternate takes
or minor flubs, like beaded curtains falling in front of the lens
during a push-in at the Blue Parrot, so don't expect many laughs.
Since the outtakes are not new to the viewer, no subtitles are
displayed.
Scoring Stage Sessions is a collection of
eight audio-only recordings. Six are Dooley Wilson vocals; two are
orchestral (I'm looking forward to a modern rerecording of Steiner's
score on CD). The selections may be played individually or all may be
played sequentially.
Bacall on Bogart (1:23:22)
is a loving tribute to the actor by his widow. She traces his life
from childhood and we learn of his early attraction to performing.
Bogart appeared on Broadway in several productions before he was
ultimately seduced by Hollywood. Bacall takes us through his film
career, punctuating his story with generous clips from many of his
films. Quite a few notable people appear to reminisce. Co-produced in
1988 by New York City's PBS station WNET and Turner Entertainment,
we're able to enjoy the recollections of several participants who are
no longer with us, like John Houston. Bogart died prematurely at the
age of 57, a victim of his decades long cigarette addiction. He left a
fine legacy.
A Tribute to Casablanca (34:37), a
1992 Turner Entertainment production, is also narrated by Lauren
Bacall. Pia Lindstrom, credited as a film critic as opposed to Ingrid
Bergman's daughter, and Rudy Behlmer - both of whom are heard
elsewhere on this disc set - screenwriters Julius Epstein and Howard
Koch, Warner Bros. story editor Irene Lee Diamond, film historian
Ronald Haver, playwright Murray Burnett, and others comment on the
film. This is an informative and entertaining overview of the film's
history and the shoot.
An unusual audio-only supplement is the
1943 Screen Guild Theater Radio Show adaptation of
Casablanca; it's complete with vintage commercials. Bogart,
Bergman, and Henreid reprise their roles in this shortened, highly
revised version. As you might expect, without Bergman's pensive
glances, eyes glistening with tears, there's absolutely no emotional
impact. The production is certainly a novelty, but it fails to engage.
An even more bizarre supplement is an 18:37 condensation of a Warner
Bros. Television remake of Casablanca set during the cold war
called Who Holds Tomorrow.
The second disc
includes a Warner Bros. cartoon featuring virtually all the animated
characters from the classic Looney Tunes. It spoofs the feature
with a cartoon called Corrotblanca (8:03). Alas, it was made in
1995, six years after Mel Blanc died and thirteen years after the
death of Carl Stalling. Chuck Jones was not involved, either.
Consequently, much of the special wit found in the Looney Tunes of the
forties and early fifties is absent. I guess I'll have to wait for
Warner Home Video's Looney Tune Collections due in October.
The
last supplement is Production Research, a series of ninety-four
images of Warner Bros. documentation; many are internal memos. There
are quite a few fascinating details buried here, but once you start
the feature, the screens switch too quickly to read the text
completely. I'd recommend putting your DVD player in the pause mode
and navigate through the documents with the next chapter and previous
chapter buttons on your remote control. The text screens are followed
by a large selection of stills. Some appear to photographically
document the film's sets and props, others seem like publicity photos.
This feature finishes with posters, lobby art, and a couple of odd
marquee photos.
The 102-minute feature is organized into
thirty-two chapters.
DVD-ROM Exclusives: What do you get
when you pop the disc in your PC?
ROM features may be found
on disc two. After your InterActual player loads, you'll be given
several choices. Visit Website and WB Online is a hot
link to the Warner Bros. Web Site. Sign up for Movie Mail
offers the opportunity to subscribe to an e-mail subscription.
Latest DVDs is a hot link to the Warner Home Video Site.
Special Events takes you to the DVD-specific part of that site.
It's from there that you can click on specific titles for more
content, including for Casablanca. Since this review is being
prepared well before street date, the Casablanca links were not
fully functional.
Parting Thoughts
Some movies
simply belong in any film lover's collection. Casablanca is one
of them. This Two-Disc Special Edition sports a superb transfer with
surprisingly good sound. The very generous supplements are informative
and entertaining. Readily available for under $20, this release is
very highly recommended.