I, like Terry Gilliam, have never dropped acid, so there are those
who will immediately accuse me of not being able to
"understand" either Hunter S. Thompson's notorious 1971 book
nor Gilliam's loopy 1998 adaptation, which remains the most
bewilderingly bizarre mainstream summer movie Hollywood has produced
in at least thirty years.
But to label Fear and Loathing merely a
drug movie - "you can't get it if you haven't done it" - is
to be a sucker. The film and its source novel is not a syllabus for
how take psychedelic drugs, it's an American fable about the loss of
hippie innocence and the rise of money-hungry Reaganistic
cynicism.
As Raoul Duke and his "attorney," Dr.
Gonzo, travel across the physically and psychologically arid Nevada
desert, we watch the flower-power generation wash away - "White
Rabbit" 60s to "White Wedding" 80s. As personified by
Johnny Depp and Benicio Del Toro, these two are a tsunami-esque force
to be reckoned with: They aren't simple personifications of
stereotypes - they are wigged out, completely insane nomads searching
for truth in a bleary-eyed land of unclear intentions and menacing
societal inevitabilities. Depp's performance is simply
revelatory: His countless hours soaking in the essence of Thompson -
staying at his home for months, listening to him speak, watching him
move - pays off in a wonderfully zany caricature, a portrait of a man
both unencumbered by societal limitations and secretly hopeful for
familial solidarity with the friends and foes he encounters along the
way. And Del Toro is clinically insane - by the time he hooks up with
a seriously deranged Barbra Streisand portrait-painter (Christina
Ricci) in a pink pink pink hotel room that eventually gets destroyed
in a monsoon of drug-induced excess, he's taken his rich character and
turned it into something more than it's ever been: He's no less than
an inimitable, terrible, mesmerizing beast.
But the really
exceptional thing about Gilliam's Fear and Loathing is that it has
aged very well. It has only been a few short years, but what may have
looked in 1998 like an overzealous attempt to enthrall today reads as
a fervent, effervescent stylistic comment on both 70s-era everything-
goes nihilism and today's hollow multiplex cinema. Yet such an
esoteric response to Fear and Loathing in Las Vegas is a minority, for
it had little impact as a commercial picture. According to, well,
pretty much everyone who saw it during its initial release, the film
is just about the worst-received of anything Hollywood has dropped in
a long time. No one saw it, but most film critics waged war against
it, claiming its was aimless, formless and not deserving of the book
or Thompson. However, The Rocky Horror Picture Show was a grade-A flop
when it was released, and look at the cult following it has gone on to
amass. One can only hope this extraordinary new Criterion DVD edition
helps fire a similar fervency in a small but devoted cult of people
who have discovered this ingenious and hilarious film. 
Those
who share my affinity for Fear and Loathing in Las Vegas - there may
not be many of us, but we do exist, don't you worry - will explode in
ecstasy with this DVD edition, a smooth-packaged double-disc with more
goodies and well-transferred elements than you're likely to find
anywhere else. If you hated it back in '98, you may still hate it
today - but give this DVD a rent and I think you'll find that it isn't
quite as bad as you thought. And for those who loved the picture, I
can't think of a better addition to your home entertainment shelf.
Video: How Does The Disc Look?
Superb. In full-tilt
2.35:1 anamorphic widescreen glory, Criterion has hit it out of the
park: The film's color palette may not be as dynamic as some other of
Gilliam's films - most of this picture is light blue sky and desert
sand yellow - but the pitch perfect quality of this transfer is
absolutely excellent. Blacks are rock solid, with generally superb
detail - even the darkest scenes reveal very fine shadow delineation
and textures. The only caveat to this presentation is some slight
edginess to the image, and perhaps a noticeable compression artifact
or two. Top of the line.
Audio: How Does The Disc
Sound? 
Equally splendid. This new. 5.1 Dolby Digital mix is
solid and robust, as is the striking DTS track also included. From the
rumbling rowdiness of the film's rock n' roll to the subtle, eerie
atmospheric effects that linger in the surround channels, both mixes
due justice to the picture's exceptional sound design. Dynamic range
is expansive, both warm and spacious across both the midrange and the
highs. Separation is excellent across the front three channels, with
dialogue sharp and crisp and some very nice stereo effects. The DTS
track is especially dynamic, with added scope - transparency is a bit
improved, and there is additional heft to the low end. A+.
English subtitles and English Closed Captions are also
included.
Supplements: What Goodies Are There? 
This
two-disc set is huge, and a a cult film lover's wet dream - commentary
after commentary and tons of making-of material. Like Criterion's
edition of Gilliam's Brazil, this is not just a nice DVD, it is a
definitive portrait of a strikingly important film Whether you like it
or not....
Let's start with disc one and no less than And
there are no less than three screen-specific audio
commentaries, all of them topnotch. First there's the Gilliam
track, which keeps up his track record for stellar commentaries: His
candor and inherent (if dry) wit is matched only by his detailed
knowledge of the material and insight into the boundaries and nuances
of his vision. A must-listen for Gilliam fans. Then we have one from
star Johnny Depp, Benicio Del Toro, and producer Laila Nabuki, and
their perspective on the film and it's long road to the screen -
Nabuki had been trying to get the movie made for more than ten years,
and Depp and Del Toro had obvious inclinations toward the subject
matter - as well as sly anecdotes about taboo parts of the making of
this rare beast: For once, here's an actors' commentary that isn't
one-note and self-serving, but genuinely reverent. Last but by all
means not least is the Hunter S. Thompson commentary. This simply must
be heard to be believed. He has executives from Criterion and Fear and
Loathing producers around him, trying to rope him into making coherent
and applicable comments about the film adaptation of his book, but the
real magic of this track is the way he flies off the handle. Scripted
or not, his appearance here is mighty strange and endlessly
entertaining. A classic.
Next up are a handful of energetic
deleted scenes, most rather short accounts that may have added
a bit of tone and mood to the picture, but were not quite of the same
caliber as the rest. They're nice to see, but not imperative to the
movie. The real gem is the optional commentary by Gilliam explaining
why they were cut, what they were supposed to have meant.
Exceptional.
Now, onto disc two. First off, we have a
comprehensive collection of storyboards and production designs,
some of them Gilliam's, some of them remnants from earlier
incarnations of the project. We also have a more traditional still
gallery with production photos and behind-the-scenes snapshots of
mayhem. Most interesting here is the addition of a selection of Hunter
S. Thompson correspondence that Johnny Depp reads aloud on camera for
over fifteen minutes. Cigarette in hand, Depp leafs through the most
enigmatic and indicative letters Thompson sent him before, during, and
after the film's production. Between the hilarious material and Depp's
ease in recitation, this extra is a funny, odd, and sometimes
strangely emotionally affecting supplement.
Also included is a
featurette and a documentary: First is Hunter Goes To Hollywood
a short (but sweet) video from Wayne Ewing documenting the trek of
Thompson's "unfilmable" book to the silver screen; second is
the even better Fear and Loathing on the Road to Hollywood, a
very impressive 1978 BBC documentary that follows Ralph Steadman and
Hunter S. Thompson (for real) as they drive from Vegas to Hollywood.
Fascinating and almost worth the price of admission alone.
But
wait, there's more. Next we have a short audio interview about
the controversy that greeted the film's screenplay (this DVD is the
first time Gilliam and his co-writer, Tony Grisoni, will get the co-
writing credit they justly deserved all along). It's a long story, if
you haven't heard it already, but Gilliam's frankness and emotional
frustration with Hollywood red tape make this a confounding,
eventually invigorating testament to sticking to your guns amid all
the Hollywood silliness. Next are two unique collections of rare
still material: One chronicling Oscar Zora Acosta, the basis
for Bencico Del Toro's Dr. Gonzo character, the other showcasing Ralph
Steadman's freaky and disorienting artwork. Also, there are
excerpts from the 1996 Fear and Loathing audio CD with spoken
word from Maury Chaykin, Jim Jarmusch and Harry Dean Stanton.
Rounding out this mega-set is the film's original theatrical
trailer (with commentary by Gilliam which is, not surprisingly,
marvelous) and multiple TV spots. The studio was so desperate
that they tried selling the film to all different demographics, and
this assortment is a splendid amalgamation of both advertising
ingenuity and Hollywood desperation. Last but not least is a
sizable booklet featuring an essay on the importance of the
film and the book by critic J. Hoberman, as well as two works by
Thompson (one of them being the introduction to his Fear and
Loathing). Whew!
DVD-ROM Exclusives: What do you get when
you pop the disc in your PC?
No ROM extras have been
included.
Parting Thoughts
An underappreciated
and unfairly maligned work of extraordinary passion, Fear and Loathing
in Las Vegas has a small, vocal group of fans, and this lucky clique
has struck the gold mine with this two-disc set. An excellent transfer
and Dolby Digital and DTS soundtracks, seriously cool packaging and
more extras than I even thought imaginable for a film like this.
There's no denying this is one of the best DVD editions I've ever come
across. Essential.