My wife and I live in the Northeast, but in early September of
2001, we were six time zones to the West of our home, enjoying sun and
sand. We woke on the eleventh to voicemail's flashing red light on our
hotel phone. It was a close family member who frequently flew on
business; he didn't know if we had seen the news on television and
called to assure us that he hadn't been flying that day. We turned on
the TV to find horrific sights. As the scene shifted from New York to
Washington and back again, I distinctly recall feelings of anxiety and
apprehension. The world hasn't become any safer since 9/11; in fact,
the threats loom larger now than then. We find ourselves caught in an
asymmetrical war where civilians are just as likely to be targets as
the combatants. As we all consciously try to live normal lives, few of
us can truthfully say that we aren't concerned. Director Phil Alden
Robinson and screenwriters Paul Attanasio and Daniel Pyne
inadvertently tapped into our fears as they brought one of Tom
Clancy's Jack Ryan novels to the screen (inadvertent, since principal
photography began in early March of 2001 and wrapped in late June,
well before the attacks). This film is an extrapolation to a worst-
case scenario, of nuclear terrorism, of The Sum of all
Fears.
As the film begins, it may be the darkest hours of
the '73 Arab-Israeli War. Israel sends aloft a single A-4 carrying a
small fission bomb, a weapon at the ready to be used as a last resort.
The aircraft is shot down, its nuclear payload buried in the sand and
invisible to the eye. It would be several decades before the weapon is
found. When a Bedouin stumbles upon the bomb, he has no idea what he's
discovered. He recovers it in the dead of night and sells it to an
unscrupulous arms dealer. The dealer, in turn, sells it to a fanatical
organization that believes its goals would be achieved by provoking a
mutually destructive war between America and Russia. This strategy
becomes all the more timely when the Russian president dies and is
replaced by someone the American administration believes to be a hard-
liner and militarist, President Alexander Nemerov (Ciaran Hinds).
When the new Russian president is sworn in, the Senate Intelligence
Committee wants to know more about him. By no small coincidence, Jack
Ryan (Ben Affleck) had written a paper on Nemerov the year before,
even predicting his ascension. So CIA DCI William Cabot (Morgan
Freeman) calls on Ryan for informed advice. Cabot may have a highly
placed contact within the Kremlin, but he wisely seeks information
from multiple sources. This sets up Ryan's involvement in what will
develop into a doomsday scenario. We follow the film's several
simultaneous threads as they converge. Ryan is in the early stages of
a relationship with Dr. Cathy Muller (Bridget Moynahan). A START
Treaty inspection reveals that three Russian nuclear scientists have
gone missing, provoking a CIA excursion that involves unleashing a
skillful and lethal agent named John Clark (Liev Schreiber). We follow
the fission bomb as it changes hands to be restored to functionality
and to be transformed into another form. And we watch the moneyed
terrorists pulling strings from remote safety.
As anyone who's
seen any of the film's trailers or teasers already knows, the fission
device detonates on American soil. This occurs much earlier in the
film than I expected. The remainder of the action is dedicated to the
escalation of the confrontation between the two nuclear powers and
Ryan's efforts to break through the red tape and bureaucracy that
stand in the way of the truth. High overhead, flying in a Boeing 747
airborne command center, President Robert Fowler (James Cromwell),
Defense Secretary Becker (Philip Baker Hall), Secretary of State
Sidney Owens (Ron Rifkin), and National Security Advisor Revell (Bruce
McGill) argue whether or not to launch a nuclear attack against
Russia. Ryan desperately struggles to convey the bomb's origin and the
probable identities of those responsible before missiles fly and
Armageddon becomes unavoidable. 
Harrison Ford had taken over
the Jack Ryan franchise from Alec Baldwin and made two successful
films, but after participating in the script phase for this project,
both Ford and director Phillip Noyce dropped out. Producer Mace
Neufeld had a problem and the solution seemed to be - please excuse
the use of the overused word - reimagining the Jack Ryan character.
Ryan would now be portrayed as a much younger, more inexperienced CIA
analyst, just starting his career in the agency. Yet, the events would
be set in modern times, not steeped in the turmoil of the Cold War.
Ben Affleck would be the bankable star. There was considerable
skepticism when his casting was announced, but as the movie-going
public would soon discover, this was the successful start of a new
franchise.
Director Phil Alden Robinson does a splendid job of
bringing this difficult material to the screen, keeping us slightly
off-balance by inserting humor early in the film. He does not pander
to the audience. His approach for eliciting a response from us during
the nuclear blast is to invest the time to focus on ordinary people
during a seemingly unconnected event and avoiding the obvious
incineration. Subtle and effective. The plot is more involving and
tense than either Patriot Games or Clear and Present
Danger, despite my admiration of Harrison Ford. Ben Affleck
conveys just the right balance of naivete and grit. The fine
supporting cast is consistently outstanding, particularly the always
believable Morgan Freeman. But I can't help share that a fundamental
premise left me distracted throughout. The Israelis are exceptionally
tenacious. I simply cannot accept the notion that they wouldn't have
exhausted every possible resource to recover a lost nuclear bomb
rather than risk it falling into the hands of one of their enemies. I
have little doubt that the bomb would have been found and
recovered.
Video: How Does The Disc Look?
The
film's theatrical aspect ratio of 2.35:1 is presented in anamorphic
video. This is a fine transfer, with rare halos and a fine level of
small object detail. Textures are ever so slightly degraded by a
modest softness. The transfer is a tad dark, with moderate shadow
detail. Colors are vivid and noise free. I noticed no mosquito noise
or blocking artifacts. This DVD offers a film-like presentation that
I'm sure you'll find very pleasing. 
Audio: How Does The
Disc Sound?
The Dolby Digital 5.1 track is outstanding. The
surrounds are quite active throughout, particularly during the many
action set-pieces. Aircraft, masses of people in a football stadium,
air combat, all are spread sonically around the room. Solid bass,
particularly during the film's many explosions, will require a
superior subwoofer to take full advantage of the audio material. Sound
effects are clean, dynamic, and distortion free. Jerry Goldsmith's
thoughtful score, far less bombastic than might be expected in an
action-adventure flick, is presented across a broad soundstage with
great authority. The dialog remains clear throughout, even when mixed
with music and sound effects. Nicely done.
Paramount has also
included two Dolby Surround 2.0 tracks, one in English and one in
French. The audio is supported by English subtitles and Closed
Captions. 
Supplements: What Goodies Are There?
There is a surprisingly generous array of extras on this disc.
There are no less than seven featurettes, all of which are
presented in anamorphic video. The quality is a tad soft, but I
applaud their being anamorphic, avoiding the need to change display
modes. The shorts are divided into two sections: A Cautionary
Tale and Visual Effects. Within the fist section we have
Casting (12:56) and Production (17:00). Each has the players and the
filmmakers offer their observations about the background of the show,
the nature of the story and characters, and the shoot. More than fluff
pieces, there's interesting material here, from anecdotes from the set
to how the plot evolved as Ford and Noyce left the production.
Within the Visual Effects section we have: Carrier Attack
(8:40); A-4 (6:25); Hospital (3:54); Motorcade (3:57); and, Helicopter
(4:53). These are very fine and revealing shorts that demonstrate how
these various special effects were created. As someone who's drawn to
special effects laden films, I was fascinated to learn what was real,
what was a miniature, what was CGI, and how some of the effects were
accomplished. In all, there's nearly an hour's worth (57:45) of
informative featurettes on this disc. The only other visual extra is
the film's theatrical trailer, which rather inconsistently is
presented in 1.85:1 non-anamorphic widescreen. The 123-minute film is
organized into seventeen chapter stops. 
This brings us to the
two feature-length, screen-specific commentaries. The first is
by director Phil Alden Robinson and cinematographer John Lindlay. In
the second, director Robinson is joined by novelist Tom Clancy. Clancy
is an exhaustive researcher, is detail-oriented, and speaks with
substantial authority about armament, military tactics, the
intelligence community, and the history of warfare. His participation
makes this an unusually worthy commentary. He's a treasure-trove of
tactical and strategic minutiae, and he enjoys sharing his knowledge
as he and Robinson are inspired by the events on the screen. A
stickler for accuracy, Clancy enjoys pointing out every technical
gaff. Of course, most authors resent the bastardization of their work,
and Clancy complains from time to time about how his concepts were
changed for the screen. Robinson usually defends himself well,
explaining the rationale behind his changes. Nicely done and
informative.
When Robinson sits with cinematographer Lindlay,
the discussion remains technical but the subject turns to the art of
filmmaking. Artistic decisions, technique, set design, locations,
lighting, directorial challenges, and expressions of regret (“If I
could do that scene over again…”) punctuate this commentary. As a fan
of such explanatory commentaries, I very much enjoyed their chat as
well. Neither commentary wastes our time with narration or endless
discussions of character motivation.
No theatrical
trailers or other promos are provided.
DVD-ROM
Exclusives: What do you get when you pop the disc in your PC?
As is the case with just about all Paramount DVDs these days, n o
ROM extras have been included.
Parting Thoughts
The Sum of All Fears is a taught, credible tale (with the
one significant exception I mentioned) that has taken on more serious
significance since the events of September 2001. Apparently, when it
was released the film-going public was ready for the sight of
terrorism gone mad, for the film exceeded all expectations by earning
more than $150 million worldwide. Perhaps we needed vicarious
resolution, a demonstration that our intelligence community will make
things right. Not for those easily upset by the current threats of our
asymmetrical war, the film and this DVD are recommended.