The Mask of Zorro seems to be vying for the distinction of the DVD
that has been released in more versions than any other. It was
released first in December of '98 with a few supplements, but this
popular film did so well that Columbia Tristar Home Entertainment
decided to release a two-disc Special Edition in September of 2001
with more generous supplements, including a great audio commentary by
director Martin Campbell. But that was before the Superbit and
Superbit Deluxe series were introduced. Now, one week shy of first
anniversary of the last release, we have a new two-disc edition that
features optimized video and audio on one DVD and the supplements on
another. Should you run out and replace your current copy? Skip the
discussion of the film and head for the video and audio sections if
you can't wait...
With the influence of Executive Producer
Steven Spielberg at Amblin Entertainment, screenwriters John Eskow,
Ted Elliott, and Terry Rossio, and director Martin Campbell reimagined
(if you'll kindly excuse the use of a term that is rapidly becoming a
cliche) the legend of Zorro. In truth, this film is an extrapolation,
suggesting that - like Batman and the Phantom - Zorro outlives any one
man to be reincarnated by a succession of noble heroes, each to wear
The Mask of Zorro. As the film opens, Don Rafael Montero (Stuart
Wilson) is about to flee the 19th Century Spanish territory
of Southern California. His brutal governorship has provoked a noble
landowner, Don Diego de la Vega (Anthony Hopkins) to wage guerrilla
warfare against his regime, disguised in dashing black garb complete
with flowing cape, and assuming the name of Zorro - the fox. The
peasants, supported by Mexico's Santa Ana and inspired by Zorro, have
risen up against their oppressor. Before he escapes, Don Rafael lays
the foundation for his future return. He signs over Spanish-owned
lands to the local Dons to keep the territory out of Mexico's hands.
And he makes one last attempt to capture the outlaw Zorro. He randomly
selects three peasants for public execution by firing squad, knowing
full well that Zorro would not be able to resist saving them.
Zorro outfoxes and outmaneuvers Montero and his troops with
athleticism, bravery, and will. Zorro will be successful that
afternoon - aided by the peasants and, in particular, two young hero-
worshipping brothers, Alejandro (Jose Maria de Tavira) and
Joaquín Murrieta (Deigo Sieres) - but the day will not end well.
Don Rafael finally deduces Zorro's true identity and brings a force of
men to Don Diego's hacienda. Senora de la Vega - who apparently turned
away Don Rafael's attentions in favor of Don Diego - is accidentally
killed. Don Diego is captured. And as a final insult, Don Rafael takes
Don Diego's infant daughter to raise as his own. Don Diego will spend
the next twenty years brooding in an uncivilized prison while Don
Rafael enjoys two elegant decades in Spain.
Diego will train
Alejandro to assume the role of Zorro. Each will be able to avenge
injustices. Alejandro is taught swordplay, horsemanship, hand-to-hand
combat, and the gymnastics that will come in so handy when faced with
danger. But the most difficult lesson for Alejandro to learn will be
the role of a gentleman. As Diego explains, "something that is
completely beyond your reach - charm." Alejandro must infiltrate
Don Rafael's inner circle; there, he will discover the megalomaniac's
plan to buy California from Santa Ana with his own gold. Orbiting this
turmoil is Diego's daughter, Elena (Catherine Zeta-Jones), who has
returned from Spain with the man she believes to be her father. Diego
desperately needs to reclaim his daughter, even as Elena is drawn
simultaneously to both Alejandro and, inexplicably, Zorro. 
Director
Martin Campbell, responsible for reinvigorating the Bond franchise
with "GoldenEye," is a splendid choice for the film. He
almost brings a Bond-like sensibility to the show. He establishes just
the right balance among subtle humor, melodrama, and action. Anthony
Hopkins and Antonio Banderas are charming. Stuart Wilson captures the
essence of a sociopathic megalomania. And this may very well be
Catherine Zeta-Jones' best performance and best looking
performance.
Video: How Does The Disc Look?
Within this Superbit Deluxe Edition there are two DVDs. Disc one
offers the film's original aspect ratio of 2.35:1 and is presented in
anamorphic video. Unfortunately, as with many other Superbit DVDs,
this Columbia Tristar Home Entertainment disc is still flawed with
edge halos, but they are much less prominent than in the two previous
releases. In my first set of , Zorro is seen against a gray sky at
7:56. Notice that the thickness of the halos has been reduced, as have
their amplitudes; yet, they are still present. I was hopeful when I
reviewed Anaconda Superbit and found halos very much subdued – almost
invisible - that it might have been the start of a trend. Alas, it was
not to be.
Halos aside, the highly detailed transfer admired
in the original releases has been subtly bested here. Small object
detail, like the many faces in the early mob scene as the three
peasants are staked for execution, is somewhat improved (but this may
be more attributable to the reduction of halos). Have a look at the
of the medallion Zorro hangs around the young Murrieta's neck as found
at 9:46; notice that the improved level of detail is modest but
visible. Colors remain splendid. Bright, colorful fabrics are vividly
painted to the screen without any noticeable chroma noise. Brightness
and contrast are first-rate; dark scenes such as the night Alejandro
steals the new Tornado sport fine shadow detail. I did not notice any
compression artifacts. Of the three versions, this Superbit is clearly
the winner. 
Audio: How Does The Disc Sound?
You'll find two 5.1 tracks here, one in Dolby Digital and the other
in DTS. Each is outstanding. Surround effects are very aggressive, and
even though this disc does not contain an official EX mix, it decodes
perfectly into a center surround. Particularly impressive is the
opening sequence in which the viewer is drawn into the screaming
crowd. With EX decoding enabled, I was more convincingly immersed.
Deep, deep bass runs through the film; only the most capable subwoofer
will deliver the sonic fireworks with any authority. James Horner's
very fine score, blending Flamenco and unusual wind instruments with
his stirring orchestrations, is presented with a revealing fidelity
and great impact across a broad soundstage. The dialog remains
completely clear throughout, never overwhelmed by the dynamic mix of
sound effects and music. Very well done.
As for the DTS track,
after careful amplitude equalization, I found the DTS track to offer
the same enveloping audio experience, but with a subtle improvement in
timbre and an ever so slightly more aggressive bass line. Each track
is excellent, but I would have to award the DTS track the status of
better of the two. A very fine audio track. 
The audio is
supported by English, French, Spanish, Portuguese, Chinese, Korean,
and Thai subtitles and English Closed Captions.
Supplements: What Goodies Are There?
As with other
Superbit Deluxe releases, the extras are confined to disc two. All are
carryovers from previous releases. First, we find Unmasking
Zorro, a forty-five minute long, fullscreen, featurette written,
directed, and produced for the Special Edition by Laurent Bouzereau.
This is a very effective little documentary, providing us with many
insights concerning the origins of the character, the origin of this
film, casting, and its production. Mr. Bouzereau has produced several
outstanding DVD documentaries and he does not disappoint. Optional
Spanish and Portuguese subtitles are available for the featurette.

Two deleted scenes have been included, presented in
non-anamorphic widescreen letterbox. The first, entitled “The Wallet,”
is an extended version of the scene in which Diego and Alejandro see
the new Tornado for the first time. As soldiers gallop wild horses
through a marketplace, a Don and his wife find themselves in the
horses' path; Alejandro saves them. The grateful Don tips Alejandro a
peso, unaware that Alejandro's skills as a thief has netted him a more
generous reward. The second scene entitled “Resolution” is the film's
original ending, which did not test well. Alejandro, Elena, and the
rescued mineworkers emerge from the dust and smoke of the mine's
destruction to be met by Santa Ana and a band of his troops. Santa Ana
thanks them and he commands food and shelter for the abused workers.
Alejandro and Elena embrace and kiss as the camera pulls back. I would
have to agree that the reworked ending is much more satisfying.
Interestingly, a third scene - available in Region 2 on its
original release, if I recall correctly - is not included. It shows
Elena and Captain Love racing on horseback as they slice melons set
upon poles with their swords. She intentionally allows Love to win at
Don Rafael's instruction. I find it odd that the studio had the
opportunity and the bit-budget to have included this scene and chose
not to. Wouldn't adding supplements not previously available enhance
the sales of a film that had been released twice before? As with the
featurette, optional Spanish and Portuguese subtitles are offered for
these deleted scenes.
In the Advertising Materials
section, you will find a Theatrical and Teaser Trailer, both in
anamorphic video. Twelve TV Spots in full screen are also included; I
don't recall these on previous releases. There is a nice selection of
publicity shots of the three stars, omitted from the Special Edition
but restored here. Costume Designs is a text feature that first
describes, then illustrates the costume concepts supplemented by
photographs of the finished products. A music video of “I Want
To Spend My Lifetime Loving You” as sung by Marc Anthony and Tina
Arena is next. This is the song heard over the closing credits and is
included on the James Horner score CD. Unfortunately, director Martin
Campbell's excellent commentary is absent here, so I guess I'll be
keeping my special edition after all.
This DVD set is housed
in a two-disc keepcase just like the one used for the Special Edition.
And as in the previous releases, there are twenty-eight chapter stops.
DVD-ROM Exclusives: What do you get when you pop the disc
in your PC?
No real ROM extras are included, but when the
supplement disc is loaded into your drive, a little window opens
inviting you to either cancel the operation or click on a button that
will open your browser and automatically link to a Columbia Tristar
web page.
Parting Thoughts
Made for
approximately $65 million, The Mask of Zorro grossed almost $200
million worldwide. This zestful film overflows with fun, energy, and
swordplay. It's crafted with great skill and written to avoid
insulting the intelligence of the audience, a refreshing change. I'm
still looking forward to the rumored sequel; in the interim, The Mask
of Zorro remains very highly recommended. If you own a capable front
projection system or a high definition-ready rear projector of
reasonable size, you will notice an improvement in the image. If you
must own the best-looking version of this film, pick up this Superbit
release.