1984 was a great year for film, both drama and comedy alike. The
Killing Fields and Amadeus duked it out at the academy awards, and
even Pat Morita got nominated for his work as Mr. Miyagi in the first
Karate Kid. Then Ghostbusters, Romancing the Stone, Police Academy,
Splash and Beverly Hills Cop left us laughing all summer long, while
the second Indiana Jones adventure Temple of Doom and Dune provided
the thrills, and Gremlins and Firestarter delivered the chills. It
seems the creative juices were flowing, as it is hard to name another
year that had so many classics, favorites and memorable flicks all
come out at once.
Squeaking in all this somewhere was the
latest from the wacky creators of Airplane! and the Naked Gun movies,
the Zucker Brothers and Jim Abrahams, who came up with another
hilarious gag-fest. Top Secret! was not a blockbuster at the time, but
has cultivated its own cult following and remains a worthy entry in
the spoof genre that hits far more than it misses. Nick Rivers
(Val Kilmer) is a chart topping, Elvis-esque bubblegum American singer
who has been invited to Germany for a cultural festival. Whilst there
he accidentally becomes involved with a woman that he met at a
restaurant, and who turns out to be the daughter of a kidnapped
scientist who lost her to a childhood lover that she last saw on a
deserted island, who then turned out fifteen years later to be the
leader of the French Underground. Got that? Does it matter?
Kilmer made his big-screen debut as Rivers, which might explain why
his performance is so wooden. However, he quickly would rise to fame
with better performances in such faves as Real Genius, Top Gun and
Willow, all in only the next four years. His costars in Top Secret!
are no slouches, either, and include everyone from Omar Sharif to
Peter Cushing to Batman's Michael Gough. It's inspired casting and
inspired lunacy, and if your cup of tea is full of sight gags and
Zucker humor, than you'll be in hog heaven with Top Secret!
Video: How Does The Disc Look?
Paramount brings Top
Secret home with a new 1.85:1 anamorphic transfer which unfortunately
disappoints. I'm not sure what condition the source print was in, but
it must have been a pretty sad sight. Dirt, grain and other anomalies
run rampant throughout, wreaking havoc on an already soft print that
lacks detail. Blacks tend to be on the faded side and contrast is just
decent. Colors are drab with mediocre fleshtones that veer wildly,
lending the film a very dated look. This film looks more like an early
70's flick than one from the mid 80's, faring worse even than
Airplane!, the other Zuckers classic that looks much better on DVD. On
the positive side edge enhancement seems to have been used sparingly
with only a few scenes sporting any haloing, and compression artifacts
are minimal. Not the worst looking disc I've seen, but definitely
below average.
Audio: How Does The Disc Sound?
The audio is much better than the video, featuring a new English
Dolby Digital 5.1 surround track recorded at 448 kbps. The front
soundstage is decent with little real separation but nice balance
between the dialogue, score and effects. Left to right stereo pans are
noteworthy but the rears are used rather sparingly, with the surrounds
only coming to life with some extension on the score. The high end
does come close to being very raspy and there are some volume issues,
with the transitions from quiet to loud scenes jarring. Low end is
also only average at best. But on the whole, this is an excellent
remix of an 80's comedy film.
A French 2.0 stereo dub recorded
at 192 kbps is also included and features French subs, and there is
also a complete English subtitle track and English Closed Captions.
Supplements: What Goodies Are There?
There are
a surprising number of extras included on this disc, especially for
for a Paramount catalog release, but on par with most of the other
Zucker/Abrahams films that have made it to DVD.
First up is a
pretty cool screen-specific audio commentary Jim Abrahams, the
Zuckers Brothers and producers Jon Davidson and Hunt Lowry, and
moderated by Fred Rubin. There is a ton of fantastic inside stories
here and it's almost as fun as the film. The bunch aren't particularly
screen-specific, preferring to veer off in many directions, and the
track is marred by a fair number of quiet spots. Yes, the group is
usually waiting for the others to laugh at their own jokes, but this
is still a must-listen for fans of the film.
Next up are four
alternate scenes, which basically are just four deleted scenes.
Presented in anamorphic widescreen, their condition is poor but they
are somewhat amusing. There is also a collection of three
storyboard sequences, all easy to use and navigate. Last but
not least, we have a silly but excellent theatrical trailer in
anamorphic widescreen and 2.0 stereo.
DVD-ROM Exclusives:
What do you get when you pop the disc in your PC?
Like just
about every Paramount release, no ROM extras have been included.
Parting Thoughts
Top Secret! is right up there with
Airplane! and The Naked Gun series, so if you haven't seen this one
and dig the Zucker/Abrahams team, definitely check this one out.
Paramount has priced this DVD somewhat reasonably at $24.99 with some
great extras, even if the transfer is lame. Still recommended for
fans.