It's been reported that British playwright Anthony Shaffer's
theatrical piece has been performed every day somewhere in the world
for the last thirty years. The play is remarkably compelling and so
well-structured that I still have vivid memories of enjoying Patrick
Macnee (better known as John Steed) in the Andrew Wyke role during his
two-year stint on Broadway in '87 and '88. Theater is a very different
experience than film. Live performances are always more immediate, but
the unavoidable distance between the players and the audience made
this play's clever deceptions easier to achieve. Mr. Shaffer adapted
his work for the screen, slightly expanding our view from the play's
single set. Director Joseph L. Mankiewicz adroitly overcame the
challenge of transforming a necessarily wordy screenplay into a
riveting film, for which he was nominated for the Academy Award. This
is a tale of gamesmanship and deceit. To anticipate the underlying
truths before they are revealed to the characters truly will take a
Sleuth.
Andrew Wyke (Laurence Olivier) is a successful
mystery novelist. He lives with his attractive wife, Marguerite (Eve
Channing), in a palatial estate somewhere in the English countryside.
Wyke is obsessed with games, not cricket or rugby, but the
psychological games people play to gain and retain control. His
obsession extends to complex board games that pit one man's
intelligence and strategic abilities against another, and to complex
mechanisms. His manor house is littered with antique automatons and
mechanized dolls. His fascination with psychological manipulation
certainly must help him in his chosen profession, but it gets in the
way of intimacy and commitment; his mind games may be responsible for
driving his wife into the arms of another man. When Wyke discovers
that his wife has a lover, he invites the man, Milo Tindle (Michael
Caine), to join him at his home for a civilized drink. Tindle
is the owner of two hairdressing salons, and is clearly not a member
of Wyke's social class. He finds Wyke's civility shocking. Rather than
being angry with the man who cuckolded him, Wyke is downright helpful.
He grills Tindle on his prospects, explaining that Marguerite is high
maintenance. When it becomes clear that Tindle may not be able to
support Marguerite in the manner to which she's become accustomed,
Wyke suggests an elaborate plan. Tindle is to steal Marguerite's
jewelry and fence the booty for a princely sum to a fence of Wyke's
acquaintance. Wyke will benefit from an insurance claim, the funds
from which would compensate him for letting Marguerite go. It sounds
to Tindle like the perfect crime, but all is not what it seems.
What follows is an escalating and dangerous game of cat and mouse.
Police Inspector Doppler (Alec Cawthorne), Detective Sergeant Tarrant
(John Matthews), and Police Constable Higgs (Teddy Martin) will be
forced to summon all their skills to uncover the truth. The film's
extremely clever plot is replete with unexpected twists and turns, and
having set the stage (no pun intended), I'll not reveal any more. Both
Laurence Olivier and Michael Caine were nominated for Academy Awards
for their performances. Each offers an intensity and range of emotion
critical to capturing and holding viewers' attention during an
extended battle of wits and words. The film's only potential risk was
the intimacy of the camera as the deceits are executed in full view;
only the very observant will pierce the deceptions to get ahead of the
characters. This is a cerebral pleasure that should please in
particular those unfamiliar with the intricate plot.
Video: How Does The Disc Look?
Previously released on DVD in a poor non-
anamorphic version, this new Anchor Bay edition is a noticeable
improvement. The film's theatrical aspect ratio of 1.85:1 is presented
in anamorphic video and the transfer is very nice. The film elements
do exhibit a few minor problems. Imprecise registration caused a very
slight random drifting of the film within the video image; you may not
notice it unless you watch for it. The film is a bit grainy, but that
simply contributes to the film-like appearance. As I commented in
previous reviews, I suspect that the presence of film grain may
motivate the telecine operator or the compressionist to adjust their
equipment such that edge halos are either greatly diminished or are
totally absent. Edge halos are, indeed, almost completely absent here.
Detail is very good, from the texture of fabrics (such as in Andrew
Wyke's jacket in the opening scenes) to small objects. Color is quite
good. Skin tones are very natural, and chroma noise is absent. But
color correction could not compensate for what appears to be a
disproportionate fading of green in the film elements. The color of
Wyke's garden and maze are a bit subdued. I didn't notice any blocking
or mosquito noise.
Audio: How Does the Disc Sound?
The theatrical release was presented in monaural and the disc
preserves the original audio. Compression, slight harmonic and
intermodulation distortions, and bandwidth limitations are all
audible. John Addison's orchestral score, which was nominated for an
Academy Award, sounds nasal and claustrophobic. The modest sound
effects are a tad on the harsh side. But the essential element here is
the dialog, and despite the lack of a convincing presence, every word
is quite clear.
A second audio track is available in French
mono. There are no subtitles, but English Closed Captions are
included.
Supplements: What Goodies Are There?
I
must begin this section by complimenting Anchor Bay for its decision
to offer every supplement on this disc in anamorphic video. Even the
one piece of material that was produced in the 4:3 aspect ratio is
windowpaned, so I never had to change my projector's aspect ratio to
enjoy all the extras. Well done, Anchor Bay.
The 1.85:1
theatrical trailer and a 1.33:1 television spot may be
found here. Unlike the feature, which looks rather good, little has
been done with these previews to improve their appearance. The colors
are quite faded and the contrast is unnaturally high. The Talent
Bios for Laurence Olivier, Michael Caine, and Anthony Shaffer are
very extensive, and each is supplemented with a filmography.
And then there is the delightful featurette entitled A
Sleuthian Journey With Anthony Shaffer. Mr. Shaffer sits before
the camera and talks to an unheard interviewer off-screen. He
reminisces about the origin of the play, and his experiences with the
film and the filmmakers. He's charming, open, and suitably modest.
Running twenty-three minutes, this is a wonderful companion piece to
the film. Sadly, Mr. Shaffer died last year.
DVD-ROM
Exclusives: What do you get when you pop the disc in your PC?
No ROM extras have been included.
Parting
Thoughts
This is a wonderful film with splendid
performances. It is intelligent and involving; when it ended, I was
unaware that I had been sitting there for 138 minutes. A very film-
like transfer - but with unavoidably mediocre sound - this DVD is
readily available for several dollars less than its modest $14.98 list
price. Highly recommended.