I am glad I saw this movie without reading the so called "critics" reviews first. This movie was one of the greatest movies I have ever seen. For critics like Ebert Roper I am sorry you have cancer, but just because you had/have it does not mean its the same kind of cancer as the actors in this movie. We do not need your sob story. Jack Nicholson and Morgan Freeman do an excellent job in this movie. The only reason I wrote this review is because of all the negative I just read from the critics, who obviously dont know a good movie when they see one. If this movie is rated any less than a B+, then shame on you. Rob Reiner does a terrific job in directing this film, also. Kudos to everyone who made this film possible, Wonderful Job! I highly encourage everyone to see this movie.