| Year | Category | Movie | Win/Nominated |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1981 | Best Actor - Miniseries or TV Movie | Skokie (1990) | Nominated |
| 1958 | Best Actor - Musical or Comedy | Me and the Colonel (1958) | Win |
| 1956 | Best Actor - Musical or Comedy | Court Jester (1956) | Nominated |
| 1952 | Best Actor - Musical or Comedy | Hans Christian Andersen (1952) | Nominated |
| 1951 | Best Actor - Musical or Comedy | On the Riviera (1951) | Win |