Movies   DVD   My Movies  Search Yahoo! Movies:

Movies Home    In Theaters    Showtimes & Tickets    Coming Soon    Top Rated    Trailers & Clips    News    Box Office

CSA: The Confederate States of America   Movie Main Page Movie Overview   Movie Details   Showtimes & Tickets   DVD/Video Info   Trailers & Clips   Cast and Credits   Awards & Nominations Reviews and Previews   Critics Reviews User Reviews Photos   Premiere Photos   Movie Stills Community   Message Board Shopping   Buy the DVD/Video Other Resources   Web Sites   The Critics: none available Start Rating Movies Now! Sign In or sign up Yahoo! Users: C+ 183 ratings  User Reviews (21 reviews) Write your own review Sort by:  Most HelpfulMost RecentHighest GradeLowest Grade Previous   |  1-10 of 21  |   Next   Overall Grade: B+ Story: A Acting: B- Direction: B+ Visuals: B+ Humor: a great tool to highlight absurdity by Erik (movies profile) (Apr 21, 2008) 16 of 20 people found this review helpful Laughing uncomfortably to a film can be an unnerving experience. But as this mockumentary on a frightening "what if?" spooled out, it seems that the director WANTED us t... Full Review Overall Grade: A Story: A- Acting: B+ Direction: A Visuals: A+ Too Real for Comfort--I walked out by walt (movies profile) (Sep 3, 2006) 9 of 11 people found this review helpful I walked out. Not because the production values were poor (they were excellent)--but because the alternate reality presented was both TOO real and too horrifying. It was... Full Review Overall Grade: A Story: A Acting: B Direction: A Visuals: B Brilliant Satire by Sanford (movies profile) (Aug 26, 2006) 8 of 13 people found this review helpful This movie danced along the edge of impropriety, but brilliantly. The premise is good and the execution is genius. Depicting this as a standard 'Ken Burns style' docum... Full Review Overall Grade: D Story: D Acting: C Direction: F Visuals: C Falls way short by D (movies profile) (Aug 26, 2006) 5 of 7 people found this review helpful The idea is interesting, what would have happened if the South had won the war. While some of it was uncomfortable to watch because of the blatant racism, you never lost... Full Review Overall Grade: B+ Story: B+ Acting: B+ Direction: B Visuals: B- Imaginative! by Thomas L (movies profile) (Sep 3, 2006) 4 of 6 people found this review helpful This movie brought out a lot of realism as to how history might have unfolded, had the south won the war. The effects this had on other nations of the world were thought... Full Review Overall Grade: D Story: C+ Acting: D+ Direction: D Visuals: C Good Idea, badly developed by Catherine d'Bajor (movies profile) (Aug 26, 2006) 2 of 3 people found this review helpful As a fan of alternative history stories and a student of American history, I was excited by the premise of this film. I was disappointed by the result. Perhaps my knowled... Full Review Overall Grade: A Story: A- Acting: A Direction: A+ Visuals: A+ Eye Opener by James (movies profile) (Aug 26, 2006) 2 of 3 people found this review helpful Delicious satire, only someone like Spike lee could get away with a mockumentary like this, Honest Abe in Black Face! The movie is thought provoking and all too reflectiv... Full Review Overall Grade: D Story: C Acting: D Direction: D Visuals: D Never found its footing by orion (movies profile) (Jan 1, 2007) 10 of 20 people found this review helpful This movie is NOT funny, NOT interesting, NOT worth seeing. I think it is surviving purely on its endorsement by Spike Lee and the fact that its premise is brilliant. U... Full Review Overall Grade: B Story: A Acting: B- Direction: B Visuals: B Critical Thinking and not just being Entertained by Brotha Earl (movies profile) (Aug 26, 2006) 4 of 8 people found this review helpful The most important thing about the movie is that if different ethnic groups review it they will have different feeling and the opinion outcomes will reflect the cultural... Full Review Overall Grade: C Story: B Acting: B- Direction: C Visuals: D+ I guess I just didn't like it by angee (movies profile) (Aug 11, 2006) 1 of 2 people found this review helpful I wanted to like it (( i really did )) but I just couldnt get into it. Would I recommend this film??….Hummmmm **scratching my head** Rent the video instead. It was fi... Full Review Previous   |  1-10 of 21  |   Next